
TruLight Blog
5-Year Cost Guide: Permanent vs Seasonal Holiday Lights
Seasonal holiday lights cost money every year. Permanent lights cost most of their money once. A 5-year cost comparison of permanent vs seasonal lights comes down to when you pay and what each payment covers. This guide lists the costs to put on each side and how to add them up. It uses no sample prices, because permanent lighting prices vary by market and each dealer quotes the home.
The costs to compare for permanent vs seasonal lights
Most of the comparison sits in four costs: the yearly seasonal install and removal, replacement bulbs and strands, the permanent system quote, and the warranty.
| Cost | Seasonal lights | Permanent lights |
|---|---|---|
| Install and removal | Every year | Once, in the dealer's quote |
| Lights | Rented in the package, or yours plus replacement bulbs and strands | Included in the quote |
| Storage | Every year | None. The lights stay on the roofline. |
| Electricity | The weeks the display is up | Every night you turn them on, all year |
| Repairs and warranty | Depends on the installer or the product | Limited lifetime warranty on dealer-installed TruLight systems |
| Add-ons later | Usually none | Optional: motion sensors, a backyard zone, landscape lights |
Seasonal lights: the bill that comes back each year
A professional seasonal install is a service you buy every fall. Some services rent you the lights as part of the package. Others hang lights you already own, which means you also pay for replacement bulbs and strands as they fail, plus clips and extension cords. Check whether the price includes takedown and storage, and ask what next year's price will be.
Hanging the lights yourself costs less cash, but the work comes back every year: a couple of days on a ladder, then the same job in reverse after the holidays. Put a value on that time if it matters to you. Permanent Christmas lights go up once and stay up, so that ladder work stops after the install.
Permanent lights: one quote, mostly in year one
A permanent system goes up once and stays on the roofline all year, so nearly all of its cost is in the first quote: lights, track, controller and installation. That price depends on the length of your roofline, how many power injection points your home needs and your local installer. TruLight is a premium system and typically costs more than cheaper 12V systems. Its 48V design keeps the far end of a long roofline from dimming and needs fewer power injection points. Prices vary by market, and the local dealer quotes each home.
Bowdrie, who presents TruLight's comparison videos, says "The light is not the expensive part of the system." In the SurpLife comparison he frames it like shopping for a computer:
"What is the difference between a $350 computer and a $2,500 computer?"
Both have a keyboard and a mouse; the price gap is the technology inside. With permanent lights, Bowdrie says, that technology is mostly the app. TruLight's has thousands of patterns and 144 effects, timers that follow your local sunset, and zones you can add motion sensors to later.
Electricity: use your own rate
Seasonal lights draw power for the few weeks they're up. Permanent lights draw it every night you use them, all year. One formula covers both: cost = power in kilowatts × hours on × your electricity rate. Your dealer can give you the system's power draw at the brightness and settings you plan to use. For seasonal strings, use the wattage on the box. Incandescent and LED strings draw very different amounts, so keep them separate.
Warranty and repairs
TruLight systems installed by a dealer come with a limited lifetime warranty on the lighting modules and control box. The warranty page lists the terms and exclusions. Many dealers also offer a DIY kit, and DIY kits are not covered by the TruLight manufacturer warranty. The warranty has no dollar figure, but it belongs in your comparison next to whatever the seasonal installer promises.
Cheaper permanent systems and the cost of starting over
A cheaper permanent kit or budget installer is a third option, and it costs less up front. Bowdrie says homeowners with cheaper systems call once they see how much more the technology can do elsewhere. "We'll tear your lights down," he tells them, and new lights go up in their place. The money spent on the first system "was just a waste," which is why he tells people to "buy once, cry once."
He also says a basic system suits some people who only want the front of the house in holiday colors. If you'll want a backyard zone or motion sensors in a couple of years, count the cost of replacing a system that can't add them.
Finding your break-even year
Make a table with a column for each of the five years and a row for each option. In each seasonal year, add the install and removal price, replacement strands, storage and electricity. In the permanent row, put the quote in year one and electricity in every year. The first year the seasonal running total passes the permanent one is your break-even year.
If the seasonal total hasn't caught up by year five, stretch the table to the number of years you plan to stay. Bowdrie says a lot of TruLight customers install on their "lifetime home," a house they plan to stay in for good. Year-round use counts too, even though it never shows up as cash: warm white on ordinary evenings, colors for the holidays, a scene for a backyard dinner or game day.
What if you plan to sell?
Permanent lights stay with the house. We have no data on what they add to a sale price. Our guide to permanent lighting and resale value covers how to present the lighting and which records to keep.
What to ask your dealer
- What does the quote include: footage, lights, track, controller, power injection points and installation?
- What power draw should I expect at the brightness and settings I plan to use?
- What would a backyard zone or motion sensors cost to add later?
- If a light fails under warranty, who pays for the service visit?
- Does the warranty transfer if I sell the house?
- Do you offer financing?
Frequently asked questions
How much does permanent holiday lighting cost?
It depends on your roofline, the number of power injection points and your market. Get a dealer quote that lists footage, lights, track, controller, power injection points and installation, then enter it in year one of the permanent row in your five-year table.
A TruLight dealer can quote your roofline so the permanent column has a real number in it.
